Skip to content
upshift
Engineering Firms

Younger firms use AI to undercut you on price. Your experience isn’t winning the proposal.

Not on price. Thornton Tomasetti’s CORE Studio builds software and AI tools for the firm and for select clients. SHoP Architects formed a sister construction company and sells advice on virtual design and construction. Each sells its expertise as an offering of its own, so price is no longer the whole comparison.

Book 20 minutes

What’s happening

AI rendering tools cut the cost and time of visualization and concept development, so a studio can submit more concept variations for the same competition budget. The cost of competing for work has dropped for firms that have adopted these tools.

Michael Rustell, CEO of Inframatic.ai, wrote in New Civil Engineer that ‘a task that once filled a week can be done in an afternoon,’ making hourly billing untenable. Document review, report generation, specification checking, and data extraction, what he calls ‘the economic engine of the fee base’ for many consultancies, are exactly the tasks AI handles well. In the 47th Deltek Clarity study (May 2026), firms submitted 32% more proposals while the median capture rate fell to 44.4%, the lowest since 2019.

The competitive pressure is compounding. As younger firms win projects, they gain experience. As they gain experience, they move up-market. The price advantage they have today becomes a price-plus-experience advantage tomorrow. ACEC’s October 2025 primer, citing Q1 2025 Engineering Business Sentiment, reports 63% of member firms have an AI strategy in place or are actively developing one, an 11-point increase from the previous year. The firms without a strategy are the ones losing to firms that have one. The federal backlog that has masked fee pressure is thinning too. The short-term extension of IIJA surface-transportation programs through December 11, 2026 left out the law’s advance appropriations, a $36.8 billion annual shortfall (NADO; Construction Dive, October 19, 2026).

Where this sits: The Three Shifts

Why the obvious responses don’t work

“Match competitor pricing”

Margin destruction. Your cost structure of experienced staff, established offices, and professional liability insurance is fundamentally higher than a five-person firm working with AI. Matching their price means operating at a loss on every project.

“Emphasize experience and reputation”

Reputation alone doesn’t justify 2x pricing. Clients respect experience, but when the deliverable looks similar on paper, they choose the lower bid. Reputation matters most when the client can see the difference in the output, and for many projects, they can’t.

“Invest in the same AI tools”

Tools are table stakes. If you and a competitor both use AI-powered design tools, the tools aren’t the differentiator. The competitor still has a lower cost base, and now you both produce at similar speed.

What’s working instead

Thornton Tomasetti created CORE Studio, an internal incubator that re-platformed the firm’s practice around data, computation, and AI. They build custom software and AI tools for both internal use and select external clients, turning engineering expertise into a product. SHoP Architects extended beyond traditional architecture into construction technology, formed a sister construction company, and now offers advisory services in virtual design and construction. These firms have stopped competing on who can produce drawings cheaper. They sell engineering intelligence as a distinct offering.

The way out is to stop optimizing the old model and sell new services built on what AI can’t do. We discover what your clients will pay for, then build the AI that delivers it. Start with a pilot: in two weeks, a working first version tried on your own client work, then a decision on production. Or start with a plan for the whole firm.