Skip to content
upshift
Marketing Agencies

Your pricing model is built on deliverables. AI made the deliverables nearly free to produce.

Charge for what the work produces. PMG, a performance agency that grew revenue 38% in 2024 by Digiday’s report, has never sold hours; its founder sells growth and outcomes. S4 Capital’s Monks is testing output-driven pricing decoupled from headcount. What a deliverable costs to make keeps falling, so price the result it drives.

Book 20 minutes

What’s happening

S4 Capital, parent of Monks and one of the most prominent AI-forward agency groups, reported net revenue down 10.8% for full-year 2025, 8.4% like-for-like, and another 6.2% in the first half of 2026, 4.7% like-for-like (S4 Capital results). Headcount fell to about 6,150 by June 2026, down 11% from a year earlier. Executive director Wes ter Haar told Digiday (September 2025): “AI is eating the agency business.” S4 invested heavily in AI and still watched revenue decline.

Say a blog post that took four hours now takes 30 minutes, and a content calendar that took a day takes an hour. A first-draft design that required a designer can be generated in minutes. When your pricing is based on the time and effort to produce deliverables, and AI collapses that time and effort, your invoices shrink.

The agencies trying to compensate by producing more volume are accelerating the problem. More output at lower cost per unit is a commodity business, and commodity businesses compete on price. That’s not where agencies want to be.

The collapse is loudest in the work that used to anchor a proposal. In agency forums this year, owners comparing what they can charge for a website build describe prices that would have been unthinkable two years ago, because the client knows a competent site can now be generated in an afternoon. When the flagship deliverable reprices this fast, every retainer built on top of it inherits the doubt. The client who watched a site drop in price wonders what else on the invoice became cheaper to make.

Where this sits: The Three Shifts

Why the obvious responses don’t work

“Produce more deliverables to maintain revenue”

The volume play is a race to zero. If AI makes each deliverable cheaper to produce, producing more of them only delays the reckoning. Clients will eventually ask why they’re paying for volume when AI can generate volume for free.

“Add AI surcharges”

Clients see AI as reducing your costs, not increasing them. Charging more for something that costs you less to produce is a conversation no agency wants to have.

“Pivot to video and formats AI can’t do yet”

Temporary moat. AI video generation is advancing rapidly. Building your business model around what AI can’t do today is a bet that it won’t catch up tomorrow. It will.

What’s working instead

S4 Capital’s own agency group, Monks, is testing the alternative: output-driven pricing decoupled from headcount. S4 cut headcount about 11% in the year to June 2026. WPP’s CEO Cindy Rose told the H1 2026 earnings call that time-and-materials pricing is “probably not sustainable” as AI speeds the work, and that outcome-based pay “will take a few years”; she named one client, Jaguar Land Rover, actually running it (Digiday, August 2026). PMG, a performance agency that grew revenue 38% in 2024 by Digiday’s report, has never sold hours. Founder George Popstefanov told Digiday “I’m not selling you hours. We’ve always been based on growth and outcomes and service strategy.” The agencies surviving the pricing collapse are the ones that charge for what the deliverables produce, not what they cost to make.

The way out is to stop optimizing the old model and sell new services built on what AI can’t do. We discover what your clients will pay for, then build the AI that delivers it. Start with a pilot: in two weeks, a working first version tried on your own client work, then a decision on production. Or start with a plan for the whole firm.